HSAs (Health Savings Accounts) and FSAs (Flexible Spending Accounts): Are both accounts designed to help employees put aside money to pay for extra medical expenses on a pre-tax basis, both have rules around maximum contributions and permissible distributions, and both have remarkably similar sounding acronyms. However, the similarities for the most part, stop here.
The Hays Research and Compliance Department often answers questions from employers who are confused as to how these two types of accounts impact each other. Most of these questions are a result of misunderstanding HSA eligibility rules, or applying these rules to FSAs. In this article, we will briefly discuss both HSAs and FSAs independently, and then discuss how they impact each other in terms of eligibility.
Health Savings Accounts (HSAs)
What is an HSA?
A Health Savings Account (HSA) is often referred to as a Consumer Driven Health Plan (CDHP). An HSA is an account through which eligible individuals can make contributions, and receive employer contributions, on a tax-free basis through an employer’s cafeteria plan. Whether an individual is eligible to contribute to an HSA does not impact whether the individual is eligible for the underlying high deductible health plan. Further, the individual and his or her spouse and dependents do not need to be eligible to contribute to an HSA, to take tax-free distributions from the HSA for qualified medical expenses. An HSA account is owned by the individual, not by the employer. Therefore, individuals will have access to the account after employment with an employer ends.
To be eligible to contribute to (or receive contributions to) an HSA, two things must be true: 1. The individual must be covered under a qualified high deductible health plan (QHDHP). 2. The individual must not be covered by disqualifying other coverage.
A high deductible health plan is considered qualified, and allows a person to contribute to an HSA, if it meets both the minimum annual deductible standards and the maximum out-of-pocket limit standards set by the IRS.
|Minimum Annual Deductible||Self Only: $1,300
|Self Only: $1,350
|Self Only: $1,350
|Out of Pocket Limit||Self Only: $6,550
|Self Only: $6,650
|Self Only: $6,750
*The individual limitation on cost-sharing under the ACA applies regardless of whether the individual is covered by a self-only plan or a plan that is other than self-only. The ACA individual cost-sharing limit is customarily lower than the QHDHP out of pocket limit for families. Therefore, it may be necessary to embed an individual out-of-pocket maximum for individuals covered under a family HDHP, no higher than the ACA limit for individuals. In no case should this embedded limit be smaller than the family minimum annual deductible.
In addition to being enrolled in a QHDHP, an individual may not be enrolled in any other health care plan that is not a QHDHP, before the minimum annual deductible is met, to be HSA eligible. Examples of other coverage that will cause a person to lose HSA eligibility are other major medical coverage, general purposes health FSAs, HRAs (Health Reimbursement Arrangements), and Medicare.
Maximum Annual Contribution
Contributions to an HSA are subject to limits set by the IRS. The limits are updated annually, and are impacted by the number of people covered by the qualified HDHP, the number of months out of the year an individual is eligible for an HSA, and the individual’s age. Both employee contributions and employer contributions count toward the maximum annual contribution.
In general, an individual’s annual limit is calculated by dividing the annual limit by 12 and multiplying by the number of months the individual was eligible to contribute. An individual is eligible to contribute for a month, if they have HDHP coverage, and no disqualifying other coverage as of the first day of that month. As an exception to this general rule, if an individual is HSA eligible as of the first day of the last month of the taxable year (December 1st), the individual can contribute up to the annual maximum, if they remain HSA eligible for the rest of the month and the entire next year.
An individual who is at least age 55 may make an extra $1,000 contribution for a year. This additional contribution is calculated in the same manner as the base contribution. In other words, it is calculated monthly, unless the full-contribution rule applies. An individual does not have to be age 55 for every month in the year to make the full $1,000 contribution. Each spouse age 55 or older, with their own HSA account, is eligible to make a full HSA catch-up contribution regardless of whether either spouse has family HDHP coverage.
|HSA Contribution Limits*||2017||2018||2019|
|Family HDHP (anything other than self-only coverage)||$6,750||$6,900||$7,000|
*If both spouses have self-only HDHP coverage, both can contribute the self-only maximum. If one or both spouses have family coverage, the family annual limit is divided between them.
Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs)
What is an FSA?
A Flexible Spending Account (FSA) is an account through which eligible individuals can contribute amounts on a tax-free basis through an employer’s cafeteria plan. An FSA account is often referred to as a Flex-Account. FSA funds can be distributed tax free if used for qualifying medical expenses. An FSA account is owned by the employer plan sponsor, not the by the individual. Further, FSAs are subject to a “use it or lose it” rule. Therefore, if an employee leaves employment with the employer plan sponsor before the account is emptied, or does not use the amount elected by the end of the plan year, they will (with certain exceptions) lose the portion of their contribution remaining in the account.
Unlike HSAs, there are no requirements under the tax-code about what other coverage an individual must be enrolled in to take advantage of an FSA. However, an employer may require an employee to be enrolled in one of their major-medical plans to enroll in the FSA. Further, unlike HSA eligibility, FSA eligibility is not conditioned on the individual not having disqualifying other coverage.
Maximum Annual Contribution
The maximum annual contribution an individual may make to an FSA is set by the employer, and is subject to IRS regulations. The contribution limit is applicable to employee salary reductions. Employer contributions to a health FSA are only subject to the limit where an employee could have elected to receive that amount as taxable cash (or some other taxable benefit). All contributions to any FSA sponsored by an employer within the same controlled group will count toward the annual maximum. If an individual makes contributions to multiple FSAs, through employers who are not a part of the same controlled group, the entire contribution limit will apply separately to each of the FSAs.
If a single employer has both a limited-purpose and a general-purpose health FSA, the maximum contribution limit is shared between the two FSAs. Whether an individual is enrolled in self-only coverage, or coverage that includes any other individuals, does not impact the maximum annual contribution under a health FSA.
FSA Contribution Limits
HSAs and FSAs
Most of the confusion surrounding the way HSAs and FSAs impact each other, are a result of misunderstanding HSA eligibility rules, or applying these rules to FSAs. If an employer can remember a few simple things, most of this confusion can be alleviated.
- HSA contributions do not impact eligibility for coverage under an FSA.
- Coverage under an FSA results in ineligibility to contribute to or receive contributions to an HSA.
- Coverage under an FSA can come from unexpected places (such as a spouse’s coverage, or an extension of the FSA coverage through a grace period or rollover).
FSA as Disqualifying Other Coverage
If an employee is enrolled in a general-purpose health FSA through his or her employer, that employee is not HSA eligible. However, if the health FSA is what we refer to as “limited purpose,” or in other words covers only certain excepted benefits such as dental and vision, it will not preclude HSA eligibility. Further, if the FSA is set up to be a “post-deductible FSA,” so that it will not reimburse medical expenses until after the deductible has been satisfied, it will not preclude HSA eligibility.
One often overlooked source of disqualifying other coverage, is a spouse’s FSA. If a spouse is covered under a general purposes FSA that reimburses expenses before the deductible is satisfied, it is likely that the employee’s medical expenses could also be covered under that FSA. Where this is the case, neither the employee nor the spouse is HSA eligible. This is true even where the employee’s spouse does not actually use his or her FSA on the employee’s expenses.
In most cases, if an individual does not use his or her FSA funds by the end of the plan year, he or she will forfeit the amount remaining in the account. However, there are certain ways that a plan sponsor can design the account to give the individual extra time to use the left-over amount.* The first option, is to allow for what is called a “rollover.” If an employer allows any amount to “rollover” into an FSA for the individual into the next year, that individual will be ineligible for an HSA for the entire next year, unless they opt-out-of receiving that rollover. The person remains ineligible for an HSA for the entire year, regardless of when the individual actually exhausts his or her FSA funds that rolled over.
Instead of a rollover, some employers allow for what is referred to as a “grace-period.” A grace-period is a period of time after the close of the plan year, where individuals can continue to incur medical expenses to be used for whatever is still remaining in their FSA account from the prior year. If an individual did not elect an FSA for a given year but has greater than a $0 balance at the end of the coverage period, he or she will be HSA ineligible for the duration of the grace-period.
*HSA eligibility is not precluded by a run-out period, where an individual has not elected an FSA for the subsequent plan year. A run-out period is a period of time designated into the next plan year, during which the individual can submit expenses for reimbursement that were incurred during the prior plan year.
The Hays Research and Compliance Department would like to suggest the following approach to clients to help them ensure their employees’ compliance with HSA eligibility provisions.
- Ensure no employees are permitted to enroll in a general-purpose FSA, and at the same time contribute to an HSA.
- Ensure that any individual who will be taking advantage of a grace-period or a rollover provision under an FSA, is not also planning on contributing funds to an HSA as if they are eligible for those months.
- Advise employees that if their spouse (or parent for dependent children) is covered under an FSA which could reimburse their medical expenses, they are not eligible to make or receive contributions to an HSA.
For more information on HSAs, please check out the following webinar, recorded by the Hays Research and Compliance Department: Health Savings Accounts: What You Need to Know